The High Court has restored a $2 million penalty punishment awarded to TPG in relation to fine print in its advertisements for ADSL2+ broadband services. The advertisements stated that customers could purchase ‘Unlimited ADSL 2+’ for $29.95 per month. The fine print however stated further conditions whereby the customer would also incur set up costs and the bundle with internet plan was an additional $30 per month for phone line rental.
The ACCC brought proceedings against TPG for false or misleading representations in the Federal Court where TPG was fined $2 million for the advertisements which were published on TV, radio, newspaper and various websites.
TPG appealed to the Full Federal Court where it was held that the relative prominence of the conditions was not important because advertisements needed to be read as a whole, not just for their ‘dominant message’. The penalty was reduced from $2 million to $50,000.
In response, ACCC appealed to the High Court where the majority restored the $2 million penalty and the approach of the original Federal Court decision – that a customer would take in the dominant message and may not take in further message regarding additional charges, leaving the customer with the impression that the total cost of the service was $29.95 per month.